Prong collars – WHY?

Personally I don’t use collars on my dogs as I believe that they can do damage to the dogs neck and can result in medical problems. so instead I use a harness. I have heard people say that harnesses are only used by people too lazy to train their dog not to pull – well this is not the case for me! I do train my dogs not to pull while using the harness I just feel it is gentler on the dog especially when you just start training them as they will pull.

The reasons that I don’t use collars is because of personal comfort and preference. Also because Tess is baldy on her neck a collar would rub on her causing sores. She is still baldy around her chest and under her front ‘armpits’ so a wrong fitting or tough nylon harness would also rub so I put a length of sheepskin around the harness strap that goes under her legs until I found these fleece harnesses at which are made specifically to fit your dog’s measurements, which is perfect for staffies as they have a deep chest so a lot of harnesses are ill fitting. These harnesses also have a from D ring so you can attach a training lead (they sell matching ones) to both D rings to help train to stop pulling and gives a more balanced control.

IMG_1261 IMG_1264 IMG_1265 IMG_0136

So along with positive reinforcement training with the clicker and treats I don’t see the need for choke, prong or shock collars  especially with the damage they cause. I myself have never tried a shock collar but I sat next to my dad at a seminar whilst he tried the shock collar on his arm, which is a lot less sensitive than the neck, he tried it on the lowest setting and it made him jump and left a mark on his arm for the entire night which was all red around it.


The above is a photo of the results of a prong collar which is meant to apply just a little pressure, not only does the collar itself look vicious but the effects of “misuse” are disgusting and the fact that they can sell theses products online or over the counter without training is disgraceful.

545026_406625516025101_999323876_n 1621690_709319202422396_911954355_n

but even without training in how to use them, how could you think that the above photos are ok? how could you continue to use it? I know that some trainers swear by them, especially in extreme cases but surely as a trainer you could use your knowledge to come up with a more humane way to treat the problem to me these (what I think of as torture devices) are far lazier than using a harness! ‘punishing’ your dog in this way is more likely to make him snap and bite, then he gets put down – hardly fair is it? The people that defend these collars say that they are humane, I don’t understand how anyone could think that this is humane in any way I would never subject my dogs to this, if they were that bad that I couldn’t overcome it with training then I would take them to a professional behaviourist. I once left a training class because the trainer took Tanya and dragged her round on her hind legs and because she was crying she sprayed her with water, but she was only crying because she was being dragged round (on a collar) on her hind legs so the trainer was causing the behaviour then correcting the dog for doing it. Dogs have to be allowed to be dogs, their own behaviour and personality have to be what the training is tailored around as every dog is different but no dog needs this extreme training aid, in my opinion. I am not a dog trainer or behaviourist but I have been around dogs and cats all my life and have found that there is no ‘one fits all’ training technique you have to work with the individual dog but I do know positive reinforcement is always the way to go as hitting or screaming at them doesn’t work and you look like an idiot screaming at your dog and getting no response from the dog! Also if these prong and shock collars are so humane and effective why don’t we use them on difficult children or criminals to teach them good habits?! A dogs skin is much thinner than ours because they have fur to protect it so any prong or shock is tenfold to what we would feel but still the creator of the shock collars would not test it on himself. I am not blaming the collar for these injuries I am blaming the owner for inflicting them by not knowing how to correctly use them as even a normal collar can become embedded and cause similar injuries if a collar is put on a pup and left on whilst the pup grows it becomes embedded in the skin, but because there are so many unknowledgeable people out there looking for a quick fix is exactly the reason these shouldn’t be sold to the general public as they don’t know how to use them. Personally I would see them banned completely as I don’t think they are necessary even if used the so called correct way, they are just not for me. If you build a bond with your dog and love it it will reciprocate with unconditional love and want to please you. Realistically how perfect do our dogs need to be? We as humans are far from perfect so why do we expect 200% perfection from our dogs?

1901332_709318785755771_1459040010_n 1505393_680882195266097_1359671787_n


4 thoughts on “Prong collars – WHY?

  1. Hi Vicky,
    Prong collars are hideous things and I see absolutely no reason to use them. They are illegal in the UK by the way.

    I am not a fan of shock collars and have never used one. There are a couple of situations where I can see a use for them but these are extreme situations.

    The first situation is where a dog continually puts itself in danger, for example by chasing cars and then only when all else has failed.
    The second is where a dog is at the high end of aggression and attacks either people or other animals. After all other attempts at correction have failed I would consider the use of a shock collar as a final step before having the dog destroyed.. I emphasise that I do not support the use of shock collars as a training method for most dogs. The only justification for me would be to save a dogs life.


    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Alan, in theses circumstances you mentioned and if all other avenues had been exhausted then yes I also can see a use for them and if the dog is going to be pts then it is worth a shot, but only by someone who has been trained how to use them correctly. The thing that annoys me is that they are so readily available online and in shops that many people use them as a first choice in training as they are a ‘quick fix’. Even if they were only allowed to be sold to qualified trainers that have certification to prove it, so that it doesn’t result in the above photos, rather than joe public that thinks a quick zap for not sitting is appropriate.


  3. Note:
    The prong is being used on the human arm incorrectly, so it’s obviously going to leave marks. You can tell it’s used wrong bc the ends, where the chain is looped through, are tou hung.
    There are right and wrong times to use a prong collar, right and wrong ways to train with a prong as well as a right and wrong way to fit them.
    One cannot blast something they don’t actually understand. It’s not a great idea to base ones opinion only on those idiots who have used corrective collars at the wrong time, fit the wrong way, and with the wrong “training methods.” Those people were/are ill informed, lack professional instructions from a balanced trainer, legitimately thought they were doing the right thing or didn’t care they were doing it wrong.
    It’s important to be informed.


    1. Hi thanks for your feedback. I don’t disagree with your comment, I have just never needed to use them. I do agree whole heartedly with the fact that these collars shouldn’t be so readily available so that they can only be purchased after training has been given and ongoing training should be given. Even maybe a rental scenario? As with most things if done/used incorrectly it can have negative results but with anything that can inflict this amount of pain should be, in my eyes, restrictively sold by qualified trainers only, not on ebay for anyone to buy so that photos like in this post, cease to exist. I use positive reinforcement training and have always found that to be enough for my dogs and I think for the majority. The trouble is sometimes people can be too quick to jump for the easiest and quickest solution and without the necessary training this can be very dangerous


Your 2 pence is welcome here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s